Skip to product information
1 of 6

SUGAR COOKIE CRUST 8 PACK BOX

SUGAR COOKIE CRUST 8 PACK BOX

CRUST ME, YOU’LL LOVE IT


What’s better than pie? Pie with a sugar cookie crust! Our Sugar Cookie Crust 8 Pack Box lets you sample our signature sugar cookie crust recipe in all these delicious flavors:

  • 2 Brookies: Combines a buttery sugar cookie crust with a rich, fudgy brownie center for the perfect blend of smooth, sweet, and crunchy indulgence. 
  • 2 Key Lime Pies: A buttery sugar cookie crust melts in your mouth, perfectly pairing with the tangy, refreshing key lime filling for a harmonious blend of sweet and citrusy flavors.
  • 2 Banana Pudding Pies: Creamy banana pudding layered in a buttery sugar cookie crust for a nostalgic, harmonious blend of textures and flavors.
  • 1 Cheesecake: A buttery sugar cookie crust holds a silky, tangy cheesecake filling, perfectly balanced with just the right touch of sweetness.
  • 1 Pistachio Cheesecake: A buttery sugar cookie crust pairs perfectly with velvety pistachio-infused cheesecake for a rich, nutty, and decadent treat.

My Pies are 4” petite pies and do not include garnishes.

$43.92 USD
$39.53 USD

Auto-renews, skip or cancel anytime.

To add to cart, go to the product page and select a purchase option
View full details

FRESHLY BAKED

ALL
NATURAL

CLEAN
LABEL

FAQ´S

DO MY PIES NEED TO BE REFRIGERATED?

Please refrigerate our Cheesecakes, Key Lime Pie, and Banana Pudding Pie. These flavors are best served chilled. When you’re ready to enjoy, let these flavors sit at room temperature for 5-10 minutes to allow for the cookie cups to soften. Our Fruit Crumbs, Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie, and Brookie can be kept at room temperature. These flavors can be served at room temperature, however if you want to enjoy them warm, see below for reheat instructions.

WHY ARE SHIPPING RATES SO HIGH?

We hear you. We understand shipping rates are high, and we sincerely apologize for that. As a small business, we take pride in crafting delicious, all-natural pies using the highest quality ingredients. Shipping is the most expensive part of the process, especially when ensuring your pies arrive fresh and quickly. Unfortunately, these are the best rates we have from our carriers, but we are hoping this can be improved in the future as our volume increases. Thank you for your understanding and supporting us as we grow!

HOW LONG DO MY PIES LAST?

Our Cheesecakes, Key Lime Pie, and Banana Pudding Pie can be refrigerated up to 5-7 days. Our Fruit Crumbs, Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie, and Brookie can be kept at room temperature for 5-7 days as well.